Will England learn from IPL?
At a time when there is talk of multi-million dollar winner-take-all matches and the increasing possibility of being allowed to take part in future Indian Premier League tournaments, it is hardly surprising that England players want to hang onto their places in the one-day squad.
But selectors do not have to concern themselves with the financial considerations of players - their job is a straightforward one, namely to try to pick teams capable of achieving consistent success in all forms of the game.
The squad announced for next month's Twenty20 international and 50-over matches against New Zealand is basically the same one beaten by the Kiwis earlier this year - except for the replacement of Phil Mustard with Tim Ambrose as keeper.
Loyalty is appreciated by players - perhaps less so by supporters - but some decisions are downright baffling.
If the England selectors have been watching the TV coverage of the IPL, they have clearly learnt nothing.
Among the highlights have been Brendon McCullum's 158 not out off 73 balls, Sanath Jayasuriya's 114 not out off 48 balls, Adam Gilchrist's 109 not out off 47 balls and, most recently, Shaun Marsh's 115 off 69 balls.
What those innings have in common is that they were all played by openers able to bat in a manner which mixed skill, power supreme confidence and audacity.
Those are the qualities needed at the top of the order in Twenty20 cricket, and if England are to have a chance of winning the ICC World Twenty20 when they host it next year, they have to find batsmen capable of taking the bowling apart right from the outset.
All of that brings me to Alastair Cook.
I have nothing but praise for the way he has established himself as a top quality, reliable Test match opening bat.
He certainly has plenty of skill (or talent or natural ability, call it what you will). But does he have the power for big hitting from the start of an innings? Does he have the supreme confidence to look for sixes in the opening over of a match? Does he have the audacity to attempt shots which would leave the authors of old-time coaching manuals weeping into their handkerchiefs?
Cook's two Twenty20 international appearances and four Twenty20 Cup matches for Essex have so far brought him a grand total of 59 runs - and in 50-overs cricket for England, his strike rate of 68 is hardly that of a dasher (McCullum's, by contrast, is 88).
Should he really be part of England's one-day plans?
Luke Wright will, presumably, continue at the top of the order in the Twenty20 side, having done the job in New Zealand. But who will partner him with Mustard out of the equation?
Ian Bell and Ravi Bopara are perhaps the most likely choices - but which England batsmen best fits the criteria I set out earlier. No, I'm not talking about Dimi Mascarenhas, although he certainly has power and audacity - I'm talking about KP.
Pietersen needs to bat as many overs as possible in the shortest form of the game and if he comes off, why not let him keep the job for the 50-overs games as well?
I am concerned that his current habit of shuffling in front of his stumps makes him a prime lbw candidate with the white ball swinging about but he, more than any other England batsman, has the talent to adapt.
Come on England - be bold!


The much anticipated clash turned out to be a no-contest as Jaipur stormed into the finals of the Indian Premier league with a comprehensive 105-run win against Delhi on Friday.
The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) today announced a 14-member one-day squad under the captaincy of Paul Collingwood for the five-match NatWest Series and one-off NatWest International Twenty20 against New Zealand.
The national selectors once again ignored former captains Rahul Dravid and Sourav Ganguly for one-day selection but rewarded youngsters Yusuf Pathan and Pragyan Ojha for their good showing in the IPL by including them in the 15-member squad for next month’s tri-series in Bangladesh and the subsequent Asia Cup in Pakistan, which was named today.
India's ace pace bowler Zaheer Khan has ruled himself out of next month's short tri-series in Bangladesh due to an Achilles injury.
Australia batsman Matthew Hayden will miss the rest of their Test series against the West Indies after failing to recover from an Achilles injury.


Kings XI Punjab scored an important win over Rajasthan Royals ahead of IPL semi-finals as they beat the tournament favourites by 41 runs in the concluding league game at Mohali on Wednesday night.
Mumbai Indians outclassed Bangalore Royal Challengers in all departments of the game as they signed off their IPL campaign with an emphatic nine-wicket victory at the Chinnaswamy Stadium, Bangalore today.


England will miss all-rounder Andrew Flintoff for the home one-day series with New Zealand as he is yet to recover from a side strain.
Suresh Raina's unbeaten 54 guided Chennai Super Kings to an emphatic seven-wicket victory over Deccan Chargers Hyderabad and secured his team a semi-final berth in the Indian Premier League today.
England all-rounder Andrew Flintoff believes that cricket's shortest form Twenty20 is being taken seriously as more money is coming into it.
Nepal's Mahaboob Alam made cricket history as he took all 10 Mozambique wickets for just 12 runs in their WCL Division Five game in Jersey.
West Indies captain Chris Gayle will return from a groin injury but spinner Amit Jaggernauth is dropped for the second Test with Australia in Antigua.
The last ball that never should have been, one misfield by Dilhara Fernando and a fumble by Sanath Jayasuriya sent Mumbai Indians into a corner they did not need to be in as they went down to Rajasthan Royals by five wickets. Niraj Patel and Ravindra Jadeja came together for a sensational sixth wicket partnership which carried Jaipur to 146-5.
Former Pakistan skipper Javed Miandad has said that the Pakistan version of the Indian Premier League may be detrimental to the country. Pakistan, inspired the success of the BCCI initiated IPL, is set to launch their own version of the tournament in their domestic scene. Even Australia has plans to begin an IPL inspired tourney.
Monty Panesar produced his best Test bowling figures of 6-37 as England fought back on an intriguing third day against New Zealand at Old Trafford.



New Zealand picked up two England late in the day to confirm a position of strength after two day's play in the second Test at Old Trafford.After Ross Taylor hit an unbeaten 154 out of their 381, New Zealand removed England's top three as well as nightwatchman Ryan Sidebottom with the home side closing on 152 for four, still 229 runs behind.
Australia suffered a rare batting collapse at the start of their second innings after Shivnarine Chanderpaul survived a stunning blow to the head and scored his 18th Test hundred for West Indies in the opening Test.
He was India's original man for Twenty20 cricket. Dinesh Karthik guided India to win in their first ever T20 international in South Africa, and led Tamil Nadu to victory in the country's first domestic Twenty20 tournament.